White elephant gift ideas everyone will want to steal

By GiftPicker ·

White elephant is the gift exchange where anything can happen. Everyone brings one wrapped gift, players take turns opening a new one or stealing one that's already been opened, and by the end someone is guarding a popcorn maker like it's treasure.

Since you don't know who will go home with your gift, the goal is something almost anyone would be happy to take. Here's how to choose one, with ideas at the most common price limits. If your group is new to the game, the rules are at the bottom.

What makes a white elephant gift get stolen

The gifts that get stolen are the ones the whole room wants, like something fun to use with friends, a treat that's easy to share, or a cozy thing people secretly want and never buy. Gag gifts get a big laugh when they're opened, but nobody fights to take one home, so if you love a joke, wrap something good in funny paper. It also helps to skip clothing sizes, perfume, and anything that only suits a very particular taste.

White elephant gifts under $25

At a $20 or $25 limit, look for something with a bit of personality that people will want to show off. Exploding Kittens is a fast, silly card game for 2 to 5 players that's easy to picture playing with the people in the room. OTOTO's Baby Nessie tea infuser is a little Loch Ness monster that stands in your mug while the tea steeps, and it always gets a laugh when it's unwrapped. The Lunar 2027 wall calendar prints the moon's phase for every day of the year in glow-in-the-dark ink, so each month glows when the lights go out.

Games the whole party will fight over

Party games are a white elephant favorite, since everyone can picture the next game night. In Hitster, players scan a card with a phone to hear a song from the last hundred years, then place it on a timeline by the year it came out. Dixit is a storytelling game for 3 to 8 players built on dreamlike illustrated cards and clever clues, and That's Dope has the group guessing who voted Dope or Nope on silly, debatable topics.

Treats everyone can share

A gift that turns into a snack for the room is always popular. The Whirley Pop stovetop popcorn maker has a hand crank that keeps the kernels moving as it pops up to six quarts, so nothing burns, and it's the gift people circle back to steal at a party at someone's home. Sugar Plum's nostalgic chocolate bars come six to a pack in flavors like Pancakes & Syrup and Milk & Cookies, which makes them easy to pass around the office. For the person who loves heat, Fly By Jing's chili crisp bundle has four jars to spoon over noodles, eggs, and even pizza.

Cozy and useful picks around $50

At a higher limit, the most-stolen gifts tend to be things people want but rarely buy for themselves. The Comfy is the oversized wearable blanket with a sherpa lining and a deep hood, and whoever ends up with it will probably wear it for the rest of the party. Owala's FreeSip bottle lets you sip through a built-in straw or drink straight from the spout, and JBL's Go 5 speaker is a palm-sized, waterproof Bluetooth speaker that plays for up to 10 hours.

How white elephant works

If your group is new to the game, here's the most common version. Everyone brings one wrapped gift at the agreed limit and draws a number to set the order.

  • Player one opens any gift from the pile.
  • Each player after that either opens a new gift or steals one that's already been opened. Anyone whose gift is stolen chooses again, either opening a new gift or stealing a different one, though they can't take back the gift that was just taken from them.
  • Most groups let a gift be stolen three times before it's locked with its owner.
  • Once the last gift is opened, player one gets a final chance to swap with anyone.

Need a gift for someone specific after the party? Tell the quiz about them, and it will rank gifts from our catalog. Take the GiftPicker quiz.

More gift guides

As an Amazon Associate, GiftPicker earns from qualifying purchases.